Nah Aziz Jan, as I did not participate in the poll, since I think it is incorrectly phrased. If you read my reply carefully again, the reasoning is all there. The poll should have simply been:
Do you agree with Ghotbi's decision to invite Karimi back to the TM?
Yes
No
and then I would have voted yes. As I said, one player can NOT make Iran reach the next WC, we need MAJOR improvement. Now which part of that is too biased etc Aziz? I know you will come up w/ something to keep this going, but I said it clearly and that is it for me on this.
If the poll was done the way you have indicated, The answer would have been both Yes and NO! Why ? because his decision was correct short term, and incorrect long term!
Not every issue has a yes or no answer, sometimes things are good from 1 angel and not good from another, and I wanted to see what most people care about. short term success or long term success.
As far as one player not making or breaking a team, although that reasoning may be correct in countries like Brazil, Germany, and other top soccer countries where all players are professional, in Iran, we don't have that luxury!
Karimi is far far more superior as far as talent, experience, and knowledge than the 6-7 players combined who has never even played outside of Iran... taking that kinda player out of the team in 2-3 years will be a major shift,
That reasoning would have made sense if we were talking about Spain or Brazil, but reality is much different than that.. we are talking about Iran.
Also, I would appreciate it if you want to attack my threads in the future, do it because u really have a point that can help TM and Iran.
Not because we had some arguements in the past and you are holding a personal grudge against me and that makes everything i put here bad!
