I think both did mistake and paid for their mistakes .. but lets not forget both contributed in TM success in past( specially Rahmati) so we should use all of resources and ofcousre make sure doesn't effect TM chemistry ! I know Ahmadi did fantastic job vs korea but I still rate Rahmati iran best keeper and by far !
I did not vote as I think it has to do with how they act and if they are willing to come and apologize and if they have really learned from their mistakes. So if they do those things and the coach finds it OK for them to return then I would support him. If not then with what they did then they have no place in TM.
I am leaning towards No.
They created some problems for Team & were childish. Plus, Rahman Ahmadi deserves to be in net and Rahmati will not play second fiddle - if he does, he will create hashiye. Naz kardesh & in true Irooni fashion expects to be forgiven & missing the world cup is his punishment.
I admit, to say yes to Aghili is tempting because he is tall, and can score from headers. But I think with Khanzadeh, Khalilzadeh and Sadeghi as backups, we are more than OK in the defense department. Plus, his long kicks up the field was annoying.
They created some problems for Team & were childish. Plus, Rahman Ahmadi deserves to be in net and Rahmati will not play second fiddle - if he does, he will create hashiye. Naz kardesh & in true Irooni fashion expects to be forgiven & missing the world cup is his punishment.
I admit, to say yes to Aghili is tempting because he is tall, and can score from headers. But I think with Khanzadeh, Khalilzadeh and Sadeghi as backups, we are more than OK in the defense department. Plus, his long kicks up the field was annoying.
We didn't really have a goalkeeping problem, but even if we did, with Rahmati in goal, those problems persist, so he's not needed 
he was our man of the match in most of TM games as we had hardtime to score and he should make key saves !
the 3 points vs uzbak away was thanks to him. you can't replace a guy with over 80 caps an over night!
sure he has his weakness but to be honest he is the best we got since abedzadeh ! and by far the best !
I have nothing against rahman ahmadi , but there should be reason why in age of 32 he is in his first caps for TM!
Not feeling confidence with him in WC !
Rahmati is a dishonest bache soosool. He saved us because it was his job. He decided he didn't want the job anymore. His replacement has done well so far and seems more honest, likeable and sometimes even more confident than Rahmati.
I don't like chaploos people. Rahmati has done his fair share of Chaploosi over the years both at club level and national level. It was gonna catch up to him at some point.
I don't like chaploos people. Rahmati has done his fair share of Chaploosi over the years both at club level and national level. It was gonna catch up to him at some point.
We also lost 2 games and 6 points because of him , but that's not the issue here , the issue is his attitude and temperament . team melli is better without him .
regarding what you said about Ahmadi and his age and why he won his first cap at 32 it is the same logic as Mirzapour played 75 times for Iran ! does it make sense ?!
regarding what you said about Ahmadi and his age and why he won his first cap at 32 it is the same logic as Mirzapour played 75 times for Iran ! does it make sense ?!
I would say no. We need to learn to become professional. We have always had "Party bazi" in our football culture and we don't really get anywhere with that. I don't like the fact that Rahmati is out of TM as I think he is a great keeper but I think with him being on the team you will create more issues similar to what we had in WC2006, Karimi and Daei case.
This would also show other players that CQ is not taking shit from anybody and if you don't perform or don't respect him or TM you will be left out no matter how popular and great you may be. I think this is a good beginning to become professional.. so I am saying NO!
This would also show other players that CQ is not taking shit from anybody and if you don't perform or don't respect him or TM you will be left out no matter how popular and great you may be. I think this is a good beginning to become professional.. so I am saying NO!
